*sigh* Yes, this is another post where I gotta get something off my chest.
But first...
What I'm gonna go type about is mainly about a day or two ago. I'm actually in a happy mood right now (like how the USA won the World Cup- woo! :D), but I really have to say this..
But that doesn't mean what I'm saying in this post isn't true. Because it is.
So... yeah. Well, here goes.........
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~
So... I'm kinda feeling a teeny bit guilty. If you actively view this blog and my DeviantArt, then you'd probably know that I typed up this Journal on DA ranting about how this sudden commenter came on here and basically commented how much they think Twinkle's Story is terrible.
Well... Now that I think about it, I think I misread her (pretty sure it's a "her" o.<) comment. Because, you see....
Right after I first read that comment, I went immediately to DA and ranted on there. And it was late my time then, too. So I originally thought her comment was about Pokemon (which it was about lol), but I also thought she commented about how terrible she thinks my writing (Twinkle's Story) is with all the cliches.
And my immediate reaction was what you see in that DA Journal.
*sigh*
But after re-reading and thinking it through, I realized how wrong I must've sounded. :(
Because now I think she was just giving her honest (unpopular, it seems) opinion about the story. And besides I've got to admit, what she said is TRUE. (She didn't exactly say the story itself/my writing is "terrible", I just interpreted that she meant that when I first read it.). The story has so many annoying cliches (yes, I know how annoying they are, you don't have to hide from me how you really feel about them :/). My writing isn't as emotional as I set up for it to be. (I doubt I actually made anyone cry to tears in any point in the story. But when (for example) I typed Chapter 16, I actually thought my writing would make/possibly make a reader of the story actually cry in real life. Now I know it honestly isn't emotional enough.).
Look, all you newcomers. When I started typing Twinkle's Story back in my beginning blogging months of 2014, I never, I repeat never, thought about it seriously. I had no flipping idea I would grow to obsess with it so much and turn it into a story where I personally view my own self-progress in story-writing. (Yes guys, I use it to mark my progress. Got a problem with that (or anything I'm saying in this post), then just leave. Simple as that.)
Back in April/May/June 2014, I was thinking of making Twinkle's Story a short (oh, the irony :'D) chapters story that is simple to understand. Like (if I can remember lol), I originally intended it to be like this.:
Phantoms attack Twinkle at field trip, Duke "rescues" her, they eventually get to love each other, things happen and Twinkle ends up being at hospitals twice, Duke and his abusive past, the hospital floor, they both rebel against how their current government is set up, they have to fight against phantoms because of the corruption, and then they lose the battle and Jamaa dies into uncontrolled corruption and devastation. And that's it.
Now if you read every chapter up to now, you know that's absolutely not the case.
Because now it's way more complicated/confusing. (Cuz I'm evil that way. >:D)
Hmm, let's see.....:
The governments.
Who they truly are.
More characters.
Fierdan is the symbolization of Zios and "Mira"'s offspring they both caused onto themselves, the phantoms. (Like how Mira cried when Zios "disappeared", and her tears mixed with Jamaa's new elements to form the phantoms. Yeah that. But with my mix on it. (;<). But he isn't an actual phantom. (That's all I'll say for now.). Fierdan himself is the puppet (of melancholy) to Soulless (more on that later on) and Zios and Mira. And practically the world(s). While Duke is their puppet as well as Fierdan's. (Duke is actually only Fierdan's evil, and he grows to be a heartless evil jerk. Doesn't know earlier because of the memory-wipe and stuff.).
Yeah, there you go. :L
So, where was I?
Oh, right.
'Bout those cliches. If I use my original ending ideas for Twinkle's Story, that ending would definitely include a whole lot more cliches than the ending idea I have now. (Not saying it doesn't include cliches, it still does. >.<). And it just sounds better, in my opinion. :3
And honestly, I'm not staying that focused on where the story currently is. You see, I'm actually more focused on how all their Elemental Powers work, their related powers (hard to explain at the moment), the 2nd story...
Yeah, I'm planning out ideas for the 2nd story when I didn't even finish the first story yet. XD
And I think I'm planning THOSE ideas better than the current story point. And the "hidden" ones with the Elemental Powers, but they're not like Twinkle and Fierdan (Duke).
And I barely even use the name, Duke, anymore. I just use Fierdan. (Ugh, hard to explain cuz I can't. Deal with it. :U)
Whoa, where is this going? XD
Oh, I basically summarized my truthful "hidden" story thoughts in a comment over on my friend's blog.
Eh, I'll just copy and paste my comment onto here. K.
This one huge paragraph:
Okay, I'm gonna tell you the truth. When I read some specific parts of The Dertavs, I imagine that instead of the POV being Suzan's, I, well I imagine, it's you who's the narrator in the story. Like, for example, when you describe Suzan as being short and playing the clarinet in band class, I can't help but to automatically think of you. Because, you told me that's what describes YOURSELF, ha ha. I can tell how much effort you're putting into this series and your writing in general. I, too, can FEEL Suzan and all the other characters there. It's like I'm a background person observing the specific scene unravel right in front of me. I can FEEL how dangerous and terrible the world is in for them. (Basically how I feel when I read my favorite novels.) And you, Mutant, are just like that (apart from the occasional grammatical error). I can just imagine you being so professional with your writing (like I imagine you writing/typing on this desk with story notes cluttered at your desk for hours and hours XD). But I can also imagine how frustrated you are at yourself for trying so hard (but that's a good thing, ha ha). And honestly, I'm so jealous of you (and everyone else). I'm personally a very self-conscious person who (at times) thinks I'm not good enough. And nowadays, I, well, feel that all you guys know what you're doing, and are, like, successful. Like, for example, you have something special in your writing that I don't know what to call. And I know I'm lacking what you have. It's almost as if writing is a natural talent for you. (I don't have any true natural talents I'm the best at.. meh.). And that's also why I'm secretly jealous of you (and Gamer too). You two have just something beautiful, whether it be in your chapters or poems, and I still can not figure out what it is. I don't know how you can possibly be dissatisfied with your writings at all. I, on the other hand, feel like it's impossible for me to actually try my best at anything I do (writing, drawing, dancing, playing my clarinet, doing homework, taking assessments... anything like that), and truthfully late at night right after I publish a Twinkle's Story chapter, I'm almost always like this: "wow, finished a chapter and it's great! :D" but then after reality hits (re-reading it) I think and know it's crap. (Yes, in comparison to your writing, I think mine is complete crap.). And after getting comments that tell me my story writing is bland and cliche-after-cliche, I honestly can't blame them. Because I think that way, too. Maybe that's why I've been so frustrated at myself, that some of my story readers see my writing in the same dark light I see it as. I really want to improve my writing (make it less bland, more emotional, like the spark in your writings), but I simply do not know how. And that's why I'll always love every written work you make, and always be jealous of you.
~ Cutepups
So yeah. I honestly think my actual writing is (at times) crap. And (at times) I get jealous of my fellow blogger/DA friends, Mutant (who I was talking to in the comment) and Gamer, because I think their writings (story chapters and poems) are better than my writing. (I strongly suggest checking out Mutant's story wip, The Dertavs, I love it so much <3).
So no. I don't adore my writing. But I also don't hate all of it. (Not trying to get attention or anything, idk. *shrugs*).
Oh my, I've been typing longer than I expected... *blinks wide-eyed*
I also got into rant-mode (idk whatever you um calls it XD) when I saw that person's comment because it was the first comment I actually got from someone who said they actually disliked Twinkle's Story. So that's another reason why I got so mad at her.
And to be honest (wow, how many times did I type that already lol), when it comes to reading comments that I have to publish on days when I post a new chapter, I do get a bit stressed out. (I'm a very sensitive person, okay.). Like for comments critiquing the chapter or story in general (you know who you are), it takes me a longer time for me to figure out what to reply so it doesn't look like we're in a miscommunication. So that's why it takes me a while longer for me to reply to critiquing comments than just straightforward, few sentence comments.
This doesn't mean I don't think you should critique my chapters. I still appreciate how you critique my writing to help me improve my writing. That I appreciate. But just saying you dislike my writing, I don't appreciate.
I really hope you guys understand what I mean by this... ^^
So yeah. I really have to wrap this post up.
I know, I know. This probably looks like a muddled mess post. I apologize for that. DX
Well, that's that.
Good night (or whatever the time is when you read this). :)
~ Cutepups
Your writing is wonderful, and I don't think that you should ever feel as though it is "crap."
ReplyDeleteSome people have their own honest opinions, and as writers, we have to deal with it with "class" (pulls out sunglasses and winks ;D) and sometimes use the feedback to improve. And sometimes we just have to ignore it.
Twinkle's Story is AWESOME, EPIC, INTERESTING, WONDERFUL (and all of the other positive words that exist :D). And it is so smart of you to use it to mark your progress as a writer. By writing Twinkle's Story you have found a creative outlet that you enjoy, and it exercises your (amazing) writing ability, which is now amazing.
I guess what I've been trying to say is... listen to criticism, but don't. (If that makes any sense. :P) Your writing is awesome. Period. ^.^
-Panda
Thank you, Panda for your kind words. But compared to my planning ideas and such to what I actually physically end up typing (and then story-grammar that I constantly change), it is kinda crappy.(Ugh, if only I could type what I plan out in my head. >.<). Thanks for your tips on dealing with criticism, I really appreciate it. Thank you again. <3
DeleteAs I said in answer to that comment: You have great ideas. It's ideas that get you going and it's the ideas that REALLY matter. All my ideas (other than The Dertavs) are complete and utter crap. I had this one horror idea... and it was horrible. I had this one fantasy-ish idea -it was too much like a story already read. And the first draft of The Dertavs had the worst ideas ever.
ReplyDeleteThe first idea of The Dertavs was that Suzan really loves reading fiction, one day before school so goes to the library, she finds a secret hatch, and under it she finds a two books (one skinny, one thick), and a dozen scrolls. Later in the day she goes to school, sees her friends, and at the end of the day she opens it, and gets sucked in. Saltar, the Creatures, and Flyer were the only things I kept. I had to break apart the cube of this story, ripped most of it apart, and restarted. I restarted three times, trying to fix the story. I'm on the forth and final time.
You have the ideas, your writing only needs a small upgrade. For me, writing was no natural talent. It took me hardwork and I chose what I wanted to be when I was older at age six to seven. I wrote and wrote and wrote so many short stories (like about two pages long), and thought they were the best stories ever written. So, it took me five or six years to actually get decent, and develop a bit better ideas and plot than a Christmas/Halloween story.
I guess it just takes practice. SO YOU BETTER KEEP WRITING :D <3
Oh, I also used to make really bad stories when I was around that age. I wrote this story when I was 3 or 4 and it was about this bird bowl (spelled incorrectly of course c;).. and I don't even know. And then one about this 2nd grader who bullied his class and there was a caterpillar. (idk o-o XD). Well, I was 5 or 6 when I wrote those stories. Then in elementary school when we had to write narratives, I wrote extremely long (2 or 3 + notebook pages long) stories compared to my classmates. And my love for story-writing became official! <3
DeleteThanks you. ^-^
Fine. If you and Mutant are going to be honest, I'll be honest too.
ReplyDeleteRemember when I first started reading your story, little Cutepups? I thought your story was so cool. I was inspired to write that short story of mine (forgot what it was called, omg) by YOUR story, remember?
And you know what- I'm jealous of you and Mutant. I'm amazed that you guys can be so excited over your characters- and you can keep going with your plot lines- when my characters are so bland and horrible, and I can never finish my stories! But you guys-you're always so excited, so happy, so obsessed with writing! And I am always in writer's block. I can never think of okay plots-or in you guys' cases, great plots. I always think of a great idea, then I get stuck, for a long time, then I give up on it. It would be there for a while, then I would get tried of it all. My dream is to make good characters who are not all exactly like me, and plot lines that make people really happy! It made me really happy to know that you felt a spark when you read my writing, it really did. But now I'm questioning my writing more than ever before, so now I'm not even sure if I could write something if I tried. Oh sure, you think there are cliches in your writing, but I really don't feel cliches at all. It feels different. If you're having fun with your writing, and know it's good after you finished it-that's writing. That's how you know it's good. And these kind of days I can't write.. All my poems have no emotion-even if they are good, like you say-and it makes me very frustrated. I'd rather have cliches and good characters and feelings and having fun writing then writing block and long nights trying to think of one more plot line, or how to put more feelings in to my writings any day. It's really, really hard, Cutepups. But I was always inspired by your writing because of your great love of characters, and your plot twists, your unique settings-you are one of the people that makes me want to write.. Nowadays it feels like I can only copy what others are doing. You've worked hard. Thank you. Thank you for your obsession. It makes me want to have an obsession of my own. <3
Oh wait.. do you mean Out In The World? (I think that's the name of it..). I did really like it, and was a bit disappointed when it ended. And yeah, I guess I did inspire you for that (and inspired Mutant too). But haha, no. When I'm typing the story, I constantly feel like I'm copying so many other people (and then with DA things for you guys, but enough of that). *cough* cliches *cough*. So please don't think of my writing as being so much more original compared to yours (or to any of you guys). And yeah, story plotting/planning (whatever it's actually called) is a difficult task. But I think you're overthinking it. Your OITW story idea wasn't bad, and that was practically from last year! You keep on telling me how I'M improving, but so are you! I know you can write beautiful things too! You guys also inspire me with so, soo much. Thank you for supporting me for so long. Without you (and others), I wouldn't be inspired to keep on writing the story. And you're welcome too. <3
DeleteYes-out in the world. Forgot the name for a second there. XD I really did want to finish it, but I just couldn't write any more. :( thanks for the kind words. It means a lot to me. But don't constantly put yourself down, you are amazing in everything you do. (:
Delete^^ :')
DeleteSo....
ReplyDeleteis the Twinkle is Souless prediction I made a while ago true?
... Oh.
DeleteNo.
Soulless possesses others. Very complicated character.